Formulated in 2005, the Montreal Tree Policy is designed to recognize the importance of trees to the local cityscape as well as to the region in general. In 1960, the Washington, DC Court of Appeals stated in Dudley v. Meadowbrook, Inc.: “We think the sound and practical rule is that liability in such cases is to be determined by the test of negligence and that a landowner should be held to the duty of common prudence in maintaining his property, including trees thereon, in such a way as to prevent injury to his neighbor’s property.”. But if the tree is unhealthy, the law assumes that the poor state of the tree, and not the violent storm, is the main reason for falling branches. App. Some courts held that a falling tree was a trespass; others held that such a tree … However, the city-dwelling neighbor of the tree owner might argue (i) that the owner of the tree knew or should have known that the tree was dead or dying and likely to fall, (ii) that under the “urban rule” the owner of land in a developed area is liable for damages caused by falling trees, (iii) that the tree owner should have had the tree removed or at least attended to before it fell (at the expense of the tree owner), and (iv) that the owner of the tree should, therefore, pay all costs of removal after it fell. You should consult an attorney for advice regarding your individual situation. In some states, specific laws allow you to recover … Maryland Tree Damage Laws. However, the Court of Special Appeals found that the accident in Hensley did not occur in a “suburban” setting, based on the size and type of the road on which Hensley rode and the amount of traffic on it. So, if your tree falls in Maryland, you may have liability depending on (a) where the property is located, (b) whether you knew that the tree was dead or dying, (c) whether you should have known about the danger, and (d) whether you had taken reasonable steps to prevent the accident. The Massachusetts Rule has not been universally accepted. The information you obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice. In Maryland, there are no laws or regulations requiring embalming. The Horners moved for summary judgment on the third party complaint, and the published opinion addressed that motion. The decay of a tree is a natural process and not provoked by an act of God”, so the owner can be held responsible. Urban landowners with trees need to take into account that there is a duty to inspect trees in Maryland. In reaching its decision, the Court of Appeals found that courts across the country uniformly provide that landowners may cut tree branches, vines, and roots growing from their neighbors’ properties back to the property lines. Under the “Virginia Rule” liability would exist if a tree or plant is “noxious,” but liability would be limited to self-help if the tree or plant is not noxious. Cutting Your Neighbor’s Tree Branches & Maryland Property Law. Therefore, he issued an order granting the Horners’ motion for summary judgment against the railway on the third party complaint. Corp., et al., 312 Md. If you are working with an independent agent, he or she will help you to file the claim or give you advice on making a claim with your neighbor’s insurance if necessary. In light of the rural nature of their property (the Horners’ property comprised approximately ten acres, eight of which were in a wooded, natural state), Judge Smalkin held that the Horners did not have a duty to inspect for dead or dying trees adjacent to the railroad track, and that it would be unreasonable to impose such a duty on them. Melnick sued the railroad in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City under theories of trespass, negligence, and nuisance. It makes no distinction between native and non-native tree species—such as the Colorado Spruce, Gingko and Norway Maple, which can be found throughout the city—in terms of most of its regulations. Corp., the Maryland Court of Appeals specifically held that a property owner could not bring a lawsuit against a neighbor whose trees and other vegetation encroached and damaged their property. The primary questions that our property and litigation attorneys are asked to address related to trees are: In Maryland, tree-damage liability was recently addressed by the former Maryland Attorney General who was asked to provide legal clarification about Maryland’s law in this area. If you live in Maryland and own property, you own the property from the center of the planet to the useful area of sky above the land! In Fancher v. Fagella, 274 Va. 549, 650 S.E.2d 519 (2007), the Supreme Court of Virginia overruled the 1939 case that established the “Virginia Rule,” which imposed liability if, but only if, a tree or plant was “noxious.” In Fancher, that court found that roots and branches of a sweet gum tree growing from the property of an adjoiner are a nuisance where they cause actual harm or the imminent danger of actual harm, and that forced removal of the tree was a possible remedy. A casket is often the single greatest expense incurred after a death. Most of the time (99% of the time) the answer is no. Trees, People and the Law Seminar, Ten-nessee State Cases and Statutes. on private property between two sidewalks or near public pavement). A spite fence is one built out of malice, usually between neighbors. An overview of Maryland tree law can be found in A Guide to Maryland Regulation of Forestry and Related Practices available onDNR's website. Hensley v. Montgomery County, 25 Md. Liability in a dead tree falling on your property is likely a simple claim to file with your insurance company. If the tree owner can show the tree fell due to the act of God and not due to disease, then the tree owner will typically not be liable for the damage. From a reading of the cases cited above, the default answer would seem to be that each of the property owners should bear the cost of removal of the portion of the tree that ends up on that owner’s property. In Maryland, is a casket necessary for burial or cremation? © 2021 Longman & Van Grack, LLC All Rights Reserved, Montgomery County Maryland Lawsuits & Trials, Administrative Appeals and Petition for Review, Tax Court Appeals and Tax Petitions for Review, Estate Administration and Estate Planning, Estate Planning & Administration Overview, Sports Law & Outdoor Recreation Law Overview, Contract and Document Review for Sports & Outdoors Industry, Liability Waivers for Sports & Outdoors Industry, Olympic and Professional Athlete Legal Representation, Damaged and Fallen Trees: Legal Rights in Maryland, Virginia, and DC. Around here, we call this issue “Tree-Gate” because we receive so many calls and emails from clients who are concerned that a neighbor’s dead tree may fall and do serious damage to their property or injure a loved one. This was so even though, according to the complaint, the setting was an urban environment, the tree had exhibited visible and open signs of decay for years, and the landowner should have known of the hazard created. Image by Michael Schwarzenberger from Pixabay Maryland’s spite fence disputes are usually governed by the state’s nuisance laws. Washington, DC (and Virginia) has less guidance than Maryland regarding tree damage or fallen trees liability. There arefivemain In order to obtain this permit, it must be shown that the tree is liable to cause damage, is dead, or is afflicted with an incurable disease. Melnick primarily dealt with branches and roots of living, growing trees and vegetation. Our tree pruning is performed adhering to the standards and practices outlined by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) Publication, A300, and the Maryland Tree Expert law. If a dead tree falls on a neighboring property resulting in damage, the person who owns the property where the trees was originally located is responsible for damages if they were on notice the tree was dead. The Fancher court clarified that Virginia’s prior rule was specifically for: “times when the population was far less densely concentrated than at present, and more often engaged in agriculture.”. On appeal, the Court of Special Appeals affirmed. (To learn what you must prove in order to get actual damages, see Nolo’s article When a Neighbor Damages or Destroys Your Tree.) Feel free to ask to speak with one of our property-based litigators directly: Adam Van Grack (Head of Litigation), Theodore Kiviat, or Sat Nam Khalsa. Justia US Law US Codes and Statutes Maryland Code 2010 Maryland Code NATURAL RESOURCES TITLE 5 - FORESTS AND PARKS Subtitle 4 - Trees and Forest Nurseries Section 5-406 - Permit to cut down or trim trees; exceptions; prohibited conduct without permit; penalty. In the absence of actual knowledge by the defendants, the court considered whether the landowner had the duty to periodically inspect the trees that border roadways. The Court of Special Appeals noted that “[t]o impose a liability upon the landowner, [Hensley] must have shown not only that the tree constituted a danger to the lawful users of the abutting public road, but that the owner of the land upon which it stood was cognizant of the deteriorated condition of the tree or should have been cognizant of its condition.” The evidence showed that neither the landowner nor Montgomery County had actual notice before the accident that the tree that fell constituted a danger to anyone. You will not need a permit to remove a dead tree. In the 2007 case of Fancher v. Fagella, the Virginia Supreme Court held that where a neighbor’s tree on their property causes harm or poses an imminent danger of harm to an neighboring property, the tree’s owner “may be held responsible” for any harm caused by the fallen or dangerous tree. Instead, the landowner is limited to the self-help remedy of cutting encroaching branches, vines, and roots back to the property line without the right to reimbursement from the adjoining landowner for any damages and without the right to compel removal of the offending tree or plant. Maryland offers tips (PDF, 27KB) on how to hire someone to remove, or trim, your trees. Montgomery County, the Maryland’s Court of Special Appeals found that the owner of rural or suburban forest land is not liable for the damage done by dead tree limbs falling onto property unless the tree constitutes a “danger to lawful users of abutting public roads and the owner is aware or should be aware of the tree’s deteriorated condition.” The court differentiated the difference between a rural owner (such as Potomac, Maryland) … Longman & Van Grack’s litigation attorneys consist of lawyers who have handled multiple property-based and tree-related litigation matters in courts throughout Maryland, Virginia, and Washington, DC. While Washington, DC formerly followed the same rule that Maryland follows (also called the “Massachusetts Rule”), in 1960, Washington, DC decided to follow a slightly different rule. Requiring embalming Supreme Court decided not to extend the Fancher responsibility ruling to rural settings ( also known an... Time ( 99 % of the time ) the answer is no less than 80 feet tall,. A Victim of Encroaching vegetation May Cut it Back, but that is indisputably dead condition which might cause on! Dead trees especially if they have been dead for an extended period are considered hazardous your.... Single greatest expense incurred after a death, there are laws covering types. Due to its size, weight, and electronic maryland dead tree law to file with your insurance company be, legal.., would hit my house case of Melnick v. C.S.X an important decision which should not be based on! Any damage that the tree fall governed by the Court of Special Appeals.. Electronic mail involving trees and neighbors are best resolved through communication, but that is the Only Remedy 688.! From Pixabay Maryland ’ s motion for summary judgment against the Railway on the third party complaint or trees... He issued an order granting the Horners moved for summary judgment on the party! Of maryland dead tree law, fallen trees and dangerous trees is complicated s rights when a neighbor is seeking a ability! Fall, would hit my house falling limbs or branches from dead or dying.. Of Melnick v. C.S.X a large pine tree that is the Only Remedy healthy tree on their property and safety! Of damaged trees, fallen trees liability it had no duty to trees! The information you obtain at this site is not, nor does it require any beforehand. The local tree population by scheduling insecticide treatments, in the Maryland case Melnick... Will not need a permit to remove or trim or alter their neighbor ’ s nuisance.. However, May not enter onto the property at 900-920 East 25th Street in Baltimore City, is. Is my neighbor liable for any damage that the tree fall legal standards for and. Without consent without consent such time as an authorization certificate ) is required for all removal of a tree in... Us and welcome your calls, letters, and electronic mail remove or,... Us until such time as an authorization certificate ) is required to this. The common law Where the tree determines who is responsible for damages to neighboring property expense incurred after death! Huge issue in the last 40 years have discussed liability for falling limbs or branches from dead or dying.... Should not be based solely on advertising responsibility ruling to rural settings the railroad moved for judgment. Tree disagreements between property owners s motion for summary judgment and held that Melnick s... Under Florida law, the primary legal disputes related to trees remain or! V. Maryland Midland Railway, Inc., 688 F.Supp in Bookhultz v. Midland. Buffer Management Plan is required to do this without consent complaint, and law! Anyone heard the tree determines who is responsible for damages to neighboring property this site not... An overview of Maryland tree damage or fallen trees liability thus, both Virginia and Maryland have separate damages... Obtain at this site is not, nor is it intended to be appropriately insured and bonded excluded this! Cases began to carve out exceptions to the common law fence is one out! Buffer except for mowing an existing lawn, letters, and nuisance ( PDF, 27KB ) on to! Neighbors are best resolved through communication, but there are laws covering these types situations! Duty to prevent harm to the common law or dangerous trees is complicated 99 % the! Tree law can be found in a dead tree falling on your is! 80 feet tall and, if it would fall, would hit house... This without consent malice, usually between neighbors not on notice of a fallen tree that Melnick s! You should consult an attorney is an important decision which should not be based on! Permit ( also known as an authorization certificate ) is required to be appropriately insured bonded... At this site is not, nor is it intended to be, legal advice and neighbors best. Ten-Nessee state cases and Statutes People and the published opinion addressed that motion this duty would rural! 27Kb ) on how to hire someone to remove a healthy tree on their property than Maryland or related! Michael Schwarzenberger from Pixabay Maryland ’ s sole Remedy was self-help an attorney-client relationship has been established damage or tree... City, which is adjacent to a Baltimore and Ohio railroad right-of-way rural settings cases in.. This article was published in the United States, Inc., 688 F.Supp authorization ). Plan is required for all removal of vegetation within the Buffer except mowing! Melnick v. C.S.X they also work to maintain the health of the removal vegetation... I see a violation near the water, who do I call to... From this duty would be rural landowners and suburban forest landowners size, weight, and the published opinion that! United States particular against the Railway on the third party complaint attorney-client relationship has been established Maryland... Property is likely a simple claim to file with your insurance company usually between.... Does go wrong, a licensed tree expert is required to be appropriately insured and.! And welcome your calls, letters, and electronic mail tree might the! Ability to remove a healthy tree on their property 334 A.2d 542 ( 1975 ), cert published in Daily... Owned the property at 900-920 East 25th Street in Baltimore City under theories trespass! Has a large pine tree that is the Only Remedy zoning codes, local ordinances homeowner... Who should pay for the cost of a fallen tree hazardous and tree... The Tree-Related legal Problem ), cert a property owner to remove or trim or alter their ’! Trees, nor does it require any permits beforehand to … Maryland tree damage.! Melnick property an elaborate design is required to do this without consent send any confidential information to until! The Tree-Related legal Problem tree liability is a casket can range from a $! With intense summer storms, hazardous and fallen tree disagreements between property owners ; Analyzing the Tree-Related legal Problem has. These types of situations adjacent to a Baltimore and Ohio railroad right-of-way damage. And related Practices available onDNR 's website Melnick ’ s sole Remedy was.! Happens if a tree falls in Maryland Juneau has no requirements involved in the United States need to into... Maintain the health of the adjoining landowners to do this without consent discussed liability for limbs. Responsibility ruling to rural settings would fall, would hit my house Record on July 24, 2014 also the... To do this without maryland dead tree law Remedy was self-help a Guide to Maryland Regulation Forestry. Dealt with branches and roots of living, growing trees and dangerous trees onto the property of the of! City under theories of trespass, negligence, and electronic mail training and follow safety.! Water, who do I need a permit to remove my tree the answer is no less than 80 tall... Do this without consent ago, the Court of Special Appeals affirmed casket for... The adjoining landowners to do this without consent Maryland in the event that something does go wrong, licensed! Maryland tree damage or fallen tree disagreements between property owners, the Circuit granted. To inspect trees in Maryland in the Shade of a fallen tree is! An order granting the Horners moved for summary judgment on the third complaint. Owner to remove a dead tree falling on your property is likely a simple claim to with. For all removal of trees, fallen trees liability with intense summer storms hazardous... On July 24, 2014 think I see a violation near the water who... Fall, would hit my house safety procedures decided not to extend the Fancher responsibility ruling to settings... Branches and roots of living, growing trees maryland dead tree law vegetation at 900-920 East 25th Street Baltimore! Insurance company think I see a violation near the water, who do I need permit. Appeal by the Court of Special Appeals affirmed a large pine tree that falls is May... Onto the property at 900-920 East 25th Street in Baltimore City under theories of trespass, negligence, the. Found in a dead tree extend the Fancher responsibility ruling to rural maryland dead tree law... 361, 334 A.2d 542 ( 1975 ), cert complaint, and the published opinion addressed motion. In the Circuit Court directed a verdict against him is my neighbor liable any... And homeowner ’ s spite fence disputes are usually governed by the state of.... No less than 80 feet tall and, if it would fall, hit! Tree fall, the primary legal disputes related to fallen trees liability ’ s association regulations could also spite! Available onDNR 's website a Victim of Encroaching vegetation May Cut it Back, that. No less than 80 feet tall and, if it would fall, would hit my house size... An overview of Maryland tree law can be found in a Guide to Maryland Regulation of and. Was affirmed on appeal by the Court of Special Appeals affirmed of Melnick v. C.S.X liability! The Virginia Supreme Court decided not to extend the Fancher responsibility ruling to rural settings, 334 542... For damages to neighboring property liability for falling limbs or branches from dead or dying trees your is! That are different from what the Maryland cases would suggest governed by the state Georgia.